CORRUPTION TRIAL STARTS IN ROME FOR 46 POLITICIANS, OTHERS
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ROME (AP) -- An Italian court on Thursday began the trial of 46 politicians, businessmen and others in a still-expanding corruption probe investigating Rome's City Hall that has revealed a well-oiled system of alleged kickbacks, payoffs, and Mafia-style intimidation to gain control of millions of dollars of city contracts.
Prosecutors say rampant corruption, which involved the management and supply of migrant shelters, sanitation agencies, parks maintenance and other municipal services, dates back years. The allegations implicate officials from both left-leaning and right-leaning parties, as well as bureaucrats and outside go-betweens.
The wrongdoing pre-dates the tenure of Ignazio Marino, who resigned last week as Rome's mayor in part because his Democratic Party, led by Premier Matteo Renzi, lost confidence that he could overhaul City Hall and thwart future corruption.
The alleged ringleader is Massimo Carminati, a Rome figure well-known to investigators who has past links to a far-right domestic terrorist group. His lawyer, Gosue' Bruno Naso, scoffed at allegations violence was used to win contracts. The lawyer told reporters outside the courtroom that corruption was endemic in all cities and that "this country is morally rotten."
Phone calls intercepted by police revealed how suspects gleefully exploited those in need, including the city's often ostracized Roma population and the thousands of asylum-seekers who were rescued at sea. One suspect was overheard saying there was more money to be made housing migrants than in drug trafficking.
Those calls showed how bosses of local criminal gangs sought to cement ties with city politicians over lucrative public contracts. Some politicians allegedly received a payment of several thousand euros monthly to ensure the contracts were awarded to criminal cronies, often without sufficient or even any bidding, according to prosecutors.
Among the key defendants is the manager of a Rome gas station, where the masterminds allegedly met regularly to figure out the next public contract to control.
In Italy, requests for civil damages can be attached to a criminal trial. The consumer group Codacons, which requested permission to do so, said more than 100 people who worked as managers or staff in City Hall are "reputedly in cahoots or somehow linked to a Mafia-like system handling the contracts."
"The irregular management of contracts has cost Roman citizens damages that Codacons today estimates at 1 billion euros (about $1.1 billion)," the group said.
Among dozens of other suspects formally under investigation and waiting to see if they will be indicted is Marino's predecessor, Gianni Alemanno, a former neo-fascist whose tenure was dogged by patronage scandals. He denies wrongdoing.
This trial is expected to take months.
|
Doctor admits taking kickbacks for prescribing risky drug
A suspended doctor pleaded guilty Friday to a felony charge of taking kickbacks and other benefits from a pharmaceutical company to prescribe its risky antipsychotic drug for thousands of his patients.
Michael Reinstein, who for decades treated patients in Chicago nursing homes and mental health wards, admitted in a 22-page plea agreement with prosecutors that he was given nearly $600,000 in benefits over the years for prescribing various forms of the drug clozapine, known as a risky drug of last resort, to patients in his care.
Prosecutors revealed in court that Reinstein is cooperating in an ongoing investigation. Under preliminary sentencing calculations, he faces up to four years in prison, but if he continues to assist investigators, the government will recommend a reduced sentence of a year and a half behind bars, according to his plea agreement.
At the same time Reinstein was entering his guilty plea, he also settled a civil lawsuit brought by the U.S. attorney's office and Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan alleging he submitted more than 140,000 false Medicare and Medicaid claims as part of the kickback scheme. The settlement calls for Reinstein to pay more than $3.7 million in penalties to the U.S. government and the state of Illinois.
In addition, Reinstein must forfeit an additional $592,000 as part of his guilty plea to the criminal charge.
Reinstein, 71, of Skokie, appeared in court in a rumpled gray suit. He told the court he’s suffering from a number of ailments, including bladder cancer, hypertension, diabetes and an enlarged prostate.
Two decades ago, Reinstein was known as one of the most prolific Medicaid billers in Chicago history, once charging the taxpayer-funded program for the care of 490 patients in just five days.
In 2009, a joint Tribune-ProPublica investigation found that Reinstein had been overprescribing powerful antipsychotic drugs in Chicago nursing homes and mental health facilities, amassing a worrisome record of assembly-line care that was linked to three patients' deaths and triggered lawsuits as well as accusations of kickbacks and fraud.
Now, six months after state regulators indefinitely suspended Reinstein's medical license, federal authorities filed a criminal charge alleging Reinstein took kickbacks from a pharmaceutical company to prescribe clozapine — known as a risky drug of last resort — to patients in his care.
In a telephone interview earlier this month, Reinstein's attorney, Terence Campbell, said that Reinstein was "working toward resolving the issues raised by the government and hopes to put this episode behind him soon."
While the charge alleges only one kickback from pharmaceutical giant Teva totaling $2,000, federal prosecutors want to seize nearly $600,000 of allegedly ill-gotten gains stemming from clozapine prescriptions.
Reached by phone Thursday, Reinstein said he could not comment on the criminal charge. But he denied any payments from Teva were for prescribing clozapine, saying he earned the money from lectures he gave at medical conferences talking about the benefits of that and other anti-psychotic medications.
Reinstein also defended his history of prescribing clozapine, which is manufactured under the trade name Clozaril. He described it as a "very useful" state-of-the-art drug whose benefits can far outweigh the risks as long as patients are closely monitored.
"I think it's an under-prescribed treatment for severe mental illness," Reinstein said. "I and many other people have been involved in many research studies that show it keeps people from engaging in violent behavior … and is helpful in suicide prevention."
First licensed in Illinois in 1968, Reinstein built a lucrative practice in Chicago providing psychiatric care to mentally ill patients in nursing homes concentrated near his strip-mall office in the city's Uptown neighborhood.
Reinstein's history of improbably prolific Medicaid billing goes back to at least 1991, when he was suspended from the program for a year after officials accused him of failing to keep records to substantiate his work.
A 1993 Tribune series highlighting problems in the Medicaid system showed that in 1991 alone Reinstein had billed for 15,480 patient encounters, mostly in Chicago-area nursing homes. He claimed in bills submitted to the system that he had cared for more than 70 patients a day on 44 different days, the newspaper found. The number of patients visits topped more than 100 a day on 12 days, his bills claimed.
For years, Reinstein routinely prescribed antipsychotic and other psychiatric medications to indigent patients based on kickbacks from pharmaceutical companies, not his own independent evaluation of the patients' needs, according to the civil suit filed by prosecutors in 2012.
According to the suit, the company that originally made Clozaril paid Reinstein to promote it even as he became the largest prescriber of the drug to Medicaid recipients in the nation. In 2003, Reinstein agreed to begin prescribing a generic version made by IVAX Pharmaceuticals in exchange for a $50,000 annual "consulting agreement" that included paying his nurse to speak on behalf of the drug and funding for a Reinstein-affiliated entity known as Uptown Research Institute.
"He quickly became the largest prescriber of generic clozapine in the country," prosecutors alleged.
Between 2003 and 2006, IVAX continued to provide other perks, including flying Reinstein, his wife and seven other associates to IVAX's headquarters in Miami, where the entourage went on fishing trips, a boat cruise and golf outing.
After Israel-based Teva took over IVAX in January 2006, the company paid all expenses for Reinstein and his associates to again travel to Miami. That trip featured a $2,300 boat cruise and at least two dinners costing $1,700 each. Over the next two years, Teva paid Reinstein more than $100,000 in annual speaking fees.
Teva, also sued by federal and state officials over the alleged kickbacks to Reinstein, agreed to settle the litigation last March by paying $27.6 million. The company did not admit wrongdoing.
The Tribune-ProPublica investigation found that in 2007 Reinstein prescribed various medications to 4,141 Medicaid patients, including more prescriptions for clozapine that were written by all the doctors in Texas put together. Records from that year suggested that if each of his patient visits had lasted only 10 minutes, Reinstein would have had to work 21 hours a day, seven days a week.
Michael Reinstein, who for decades treated patients in Chicago nursing homes and mental health wards, admitted in a 22-page plea agreement with prosecutors that he was given nearly $600,000 in benefits over the years for prescribing various forms of the drug clozapine, known as a risky drug of last resort, to patients in his care.
Prosecutors revealed in court that Reinstein is cooperating in an ongoing investigation. Under preliminary sentencing calculations, he faces up to four years in prison, but if he continues to assist investigators, the government will recommend a reduced sentence of a year and a half behind bars, according to his plea agreement.
At the same time Reinstein was entering his guilty plea, he also settled a civil lawsuit brought by the U.S. attorney's office and Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan alleging he submitted more than 140,000 false Medicare and Medicaid claims as part of the kickback scheme. The settlement calls for Reinstein to pay more than $3.7 million in penalties to the U.S. government and the state of Illinois.
In addition, Reinstein must forfeit an additional $592,000 as part of his guilty plea to the criminal charge.
Reinstein, 71, of Skokie, appeared in court in a rumpled gray suit. He told the court he’s suffering from a number of ailments, including bladder cancer, hypertension, diabetes and an enlarged prostate.
Two decades ago, Reinstein was known as one of the most prolific Medicaid billers in Chicago history, once charging the taxpayer-funded program for the care of 490 patients in just five days.
Now, six months after state regulators indefinitely suspended Reinstein's medical license, federal authorities filed a criminal charge alleging Reinstein took kickbacks from a pharmaceutical company to prescribe clozapine — known as a risky drug of last resort — to patients in his care.
In a telephone interview earlier this month, Reinstein's attorney, Terence Campbell, said that Reinstein was "working toward resolving the issues raised by the government and hopes to put this episode behind him soon."
While the charge alleges only one kickback from pharmaceutical giant Teva totaling $2,000, federal prosecutors want to seize nearly $600,000 of allegedly ill-gotten gains stemming from clozapine prescriptions.
Reached by phone Thursday, Reinstein said he could not comment on the criminal charge. But he denied any payments from Teva were for prescribing clozapine, saying he earned the money from lectures he gave at medical conferences talking about the benefits of that and other anti-psychotic medications.
Reinstein also defended his history of prescribing clozapine, which is manufactured under the trade name Clozaril. He described it as a "very useful" state-of-the-art drug whose benefits can far outweigh the risks as long as patients are closely monitored.
First licensed in Illinois in 1968, Reinstein built a lucrative practice in Chicago providing psychiatric care to mentally ill patients in nursing homes concentrated near his strip-mall office in the city's Uptown neighborhood.
Reinstein's history of improbably prolific Medicaid billing goes back to at least 1991, when he was suspended from the program for a year after officials accused him of failing to keep records to substantiate his work.
For years, Reinstein routinely prescribed antipsychotic and other psychiatric medications to indigent patients based on kickbacks from pharmaceutical companies, not his own independent evaluation of the patients' needs, according to the civil suit filed by prosecutors in 2012.
According to the suit, the company that originally made Clozaril paid Reinstein to promote it even as he became the largest prescriber of the drug to Medicaid recipients in the nation. In 2003, Reinstein agreed to begin prescribing a generic version made by IVAX Pharmaceuticals in exchange for a $50,000 annual "consulting agreement" that included paying his nurse to speak on behalf of the drug and funding for a Reinstein-affiliated entity known as Uptown Research Institute.
"He quickly became the largest prescriber of generic clozapine in the country," prosecutors alleged.
Between 2003 and 2006, IVAX continued to provide other perks, including flying Reinstein, his wife and seven other associates to IVAX's headquarters in Miami, where the entourage went on fishing trips, a boat cruise and golf outing.
After Israel-based Teva took over IVAX in January 2006, the company paid all expenses for Reinstein and his associates to again travel to Miami. That trip featured a $2,300 boat cruise and at least two dinners costing $1,700 each. Over the next two years, Teva paid Reinstein more than $100,000 in annual speaking fees.
Teva, also sued by federal and state officials over the alleged kickbacks to Reinstein, agreed to settle the litigation last March by paying $27.6 million. The company did not admit wrongdoing.
The Tribune-ProPublica investigation found that in 2007 Reinstein prescribed various medications to 4,141 Medicaid patients, including more prescriptions for clozapine that were written by all the doctors in Texas put together. Records from that year suggested that if each of his patient visits had lasted only 10 minutes, Reinstein would have had to work 21 hours a day, seven days a week.
Originally developed in the 1960s, clozapine has potentially severe side effects, including seizures, a decrease in white blood cells and inflammation of the heart wall. It is typically prescribed only for patients that have not responded to other treatments. Several studies, however, have lauded the drug's ability to reduce the symptoms of schizophrenia, particularly in patients who have harmed themselves in the past or attempted suicide.
In his comments Thursday to the Tribune, Reinstein said there are risks with any kind of psychiatric care — including not medicating a patient enough — and that clozapine has been unfairly portrayed as dangerous. He said he was not aware of any patient of his who had died from the drug since 2007.
"I'm not trying to be cavalier about it — anyone on Clozaril or any other psychotropic medication needs to be monitored carefully," Reinstein said. "But the drug is not by itself dangerous."