Our mission is to expose and remedy corruption in the Probate Court of Cook County, Illinois. We assist, educate and enlighten families of the dead, the dying, the disabled and the aged to better understand their rights in order to protect themselves from the excesses of the Probate Court of Cook County. ProbateSharks.com is dedicated to networking the human element of people to people. We join together in reforming the corrupt Cook County Probate Court system.
Unexpected medical expenses, of course, can often add a little fuel to that fire in terms of your annual deductible. For example, Peter Drier, 37, signed a pile of consent forms before a surgery for herniated disks in his neck. Mr. Drier is a bank technology manager who had researched his insurance coverage. So when large bills started arriving, he knew a majority of the charges would be covered by insurance. What he wasn’t expecting was a $117,000 charge from a doctor he had not met before surgery.
He had some medical bills from the Lenox Hill hospital where he got his surgery done, a bill for the anesthesiologist and another one for the orthopedist. But this particular bill was from a neurosurgeon, Dr. Harrison Mu, and Drier knew nothing about him being related to his surgery.
A common sentiment about the practice is that doctors are using the method to be able to charge higher prices in a climate where insurers are paying out less and less to healthcare providers. The practice has even gotten its own term, referred to as “drive by doctors”.
Unfortunately, this kind of thing happens sometimes, maybe more often than it rightfully should. And like the bank manager who did all of his homework and filed all of his paperwork, it can even happen to people who make no mistakes.
And when it does happen—even if you are the most organized file keeper in the whole world—it will always catch you off guard. That’s why it is called an “unexpected medical expense.”
Current laws within the United States do not require that a patient give consent to every medical person or office that contributes to the person’s treatment. There are also no laws holding physicians accountable for who they ask to assist with a procedure or whether or not the doctors they request are necessary or even beneficial to patients. This type of price gouging must be dealt with before more are affected.
PALM DESERT, Calif., July 31 -- The California Department of Insurance issued the following news release: John Paul Slawinski, 59, was arrested at his home in Palm Desert on July 29, and is being arraigned on Friday, August 1, at1:30 p.m. at the Riverside Hall of Justice, Department 411,4100 Main St, Riverside. Slawinski is charged with five felony counts of financial elder abuse and five counts of burglary for allegedly ripping off five senior citizens for more than $2 million through the sale and surrender of investment annuity products. Bail is set at $2,000,000. An investigation was launched by the Department of Insurance after receiving complaints regarding Slawinski's business practices involving the sale and surrender of annuity products. Investigators allege that Slawinski, a licensed insurance agent, convinced some victims to surrender annuities and investment products with the promise of higher returns through new investments and conned other victims into giving him money to invest for them. Slawinski did not purchase annuities or investment products, nor did he refund the victims' money. "I find it particularly appalling when people in the position of trust violate that trust and take advantage of vulnerable senior citizens," said Commissioner Dave Jones. "Consumers should be able to trust their agent when making important insurance decisions. Consumers often rely on the advice of their agent when they are taken advantage of the result is often devastating." Slawinski concealed his theft by providing the victims with fraudulent financial statements, and by issuing minimum investment payments to lead them to believe their insurance investment and life savings were secure. The Department of Insurance is looking for additional victims in this case and encourages anyone that may have done business with Slawinski and/or JPS Insurance Services to contact the Rancho Cucamonga Regional Office at (909) 919-2200. The Riverside County District Attorney's Office -Elder Abuse Unit is prosecuting the case. This case is being investigated and prosecuted under the Life and Annuity Consumer Protection Program (LACPP). LACPP provides grant funds to counties for the prosecution of financial abuse in life insurance and annuity product transactions. CC AutoTriage5rn-140801-30FurigayJane-4816193 30FurigayJane
John Clemmons waits outside Metro booking to turn himself in last November. Clemmons pleaded guilty to stealing thousands from wards he had been assigned to protect. / John Partipilo / File / The Tennessean
John E. Clemmons is serving an 18-year sentence in state prison.
Bond insurance has provided partial reimbursement in three cases Clemmons handled. If a judge rules that Clemmons violated the terms of his insurance policy, no payments would be made to his victims.
He still faces the prospect of judgments in two other cases. involving Donald E. Griggs and William C. Link.
More
The insurance company that provided malpractice coverage to jailed Nashville attorney John E. Clemmons is asking a federal judge to declare they have no responsibility to help pay back his victims who lost more than $1 million.
If the judge agrees, the amount Clemmons’ victims would receive could be smaller than expected.
In a suit filed last week in U.S. District Court in Nashville, lawyers for the Hanover Insurance Company stated that Clemmons’ policy does not apply in cases where he broke the law. Clemmons pled guilty in Davidson and Rutherford counties to theft from his clients.
Clemmons is currently serving an 18-year prison sentence at the state prison at the Charles B. Bass Correctional Complex in Nashville.
In its complaint, the insurance company cited several provisions of the policy they say Clemmons violated, including “any intentional, dishonest, criminal, malicious or fraudulent act or omission.”
The suit cites pending legal actions against Clemmons in three Davidson County cases, his guilty pleas to theft charges and the suspension of his license to practice law.
“Clemmons admitted his misappropriation,” the suit states.
Though the move by the insurance company was not unexpected, one of the lawyers who now represents some of the victims says he is concerned that some may never be fully repaid. The malpractice policy could have provided an estimated $300,000.
“I’m worried about it,” said Paul Gontarek, who was appointed to take over some of the cases by Probate Judge David “Randy” Kennedy.
An even grimmer assessment came from Michael Hoskins, who represents the heirs of another former Clemmons client.
“The estate’s prospects for a full recovery are bleak because Clemmons apparently blew all the money financing his lavish and reckless lifestyle,” Hoskins said in an email response to questions.
Prosecutors in the Clemmons criminal cases have stated that Clemmons spent his clients’ money on gambling at casinos in a number of states.
Court records show that bond insurance that Clemmons was required to purchase has provided at least partial reimbursement in three of the cases including the one being handled by Hoskins.
The victim in Rutherford County, Russell Church, has been repaid all that he was owed, a little over $120,000, according to court officials. Church’s was the first case to become public.
Gontarek said his next step will be to get judgments against Clemmons in the cases of Donald E. Griggs and William C. Link.
“Then we’ll attempt to recover from him personally,” said Gontarek.
The victims also can collect from the Tennessee Lawyers Fund for Client Protection, but the maximum amount that can be claimed for any one attorney, regardless of how many victims there are, is $250,000.
A WWII Veteran known for his integrity and love of family, he worked hard his entire life to give them the best upbringing and memories he possibly could. He taught his young ones to always be honest and to keep their word without hesitation. To him, that was ultimately important and his example served well.
Little did he know, as he raised his children in honor and honesty, that one day he would be the victim of a breach of trust by one, who should have been his champion, during a devastating medical crisis. He trusted and he was betrayed. Never again shall his life be as once promised. Deceit won the battle that day, but the truth was not conquered. Truth fights on and strives to win the war against those who deny care for profit and because they can.
Truth and knowledge will bring the deceit and trickery into the light and hopefully prevent others from being denied proper care at critical moments. People deserve better than that.People should be able to trust the caregivers and providers. People deserve the chance to recover and live on in dignity and with purpose to whatever degree is theirs to behold. People should and it is time eyes are opened and the truth be seen by a population unaware. It’s time people rather than profits trump and honesty prevail. A Breach of Trust is never acceptable and it shan’t be silently tolerated!
Be intolerant — add your voice in objection to deceit and trickery that wrongfully denies coverage!
A Bucks County lawyer was indicted for allegedly defrauding a client’s estate of more than $1.7 million, federal prosecutors in Philadelphia said Thursday. Randolph Scott, 70, of Doylestown, Pa., who maintained his own law firm in Warrington, was charged with one count of mail fraud, two counts of aggravated identity theft, one count of tax evasion, one count of attempting to interfere with administration of internal revenue laws and three counts of failure to file income tax returns.
According to the indictment, between December 2005 and October 2011, while representing the estate of John C. Bready, Scott diverted approximately $1.76 million of estate funds to his law office accounts. Because the estate was valued at more than $6 million at the time of Bready’s death in 2005, federal law required that a federal estate tax return be filed which would have resulted in approximately $520,351 being paid to the Internal Revenue Service. The indictment alleges that Scott purposefully failed to file the required form in order to keep enough money in the estate to pay its beneficiaries and to avoid detection of the theft.
Prosecutors also said after the estate’s executor died in 2009, Scott failed to disclose the death so that the investment account manager would continue to send the executor’s checks to Scott’s law firm. Scott then allegedly forged the executor’s signature and deposited the checks into his law firm’s account. Prosecutors said Scott also had the successor executor sign a document renouncing the position of successor executor so that Scott could continue to forge the signature of the deceased executor and divert money belonging to the estate.
In addition to the charges, the indictment contains a notice of forfeiture seeking $1.76 million.
Nino Tinari, Scott’s lawyer, said his client denies the charges as presented in the indictment. Scott is set to be arraigned Friday.
A Bucks County lawyer was indicted for allegedly defrauding a client’s estate of more than $1.7 million, federal prosecutors in Philadelphia said Thursday. Randolph Scott, 70, of Doylestown, Pa., who maintained his own law firm in Warrington, was charged with one count of mail fraud, two counts of aggravated identity theft, one count of tax evasion, one count of attempting to interfere with administration of internal revenue laws and three counts of failure to file income tax returns.
According to the indictment, between December 2005 and October 2011, while representing the estate of John C. Bready, Scott diverted approximately $1.76 million of estate funds to his law office accounts. Because the estate was valued at more than $6 million at the time of Bready’s death in 2005, federal law required that a federal estate tax return be filed which would have resulted in approximately $520,351 being paid to the Internal Revenue Service. The indictment alleges that Scott purposefully failed to file the required form in order to keep enough money in the estate to pay its beneficiaries and to avoid detection of the theft.
Prosecutors also said after the estate’s executor died in 2009, Scott failed to disclose the death so that the investment account manager would continue to send the executor’s checks to Scott’s law firm. Scott then allegedly forged the executor’s signature and deposited the checks into his law firm’s account. Prosecutors said Scott also had the successor executor sign a document renouncing the position of successor executor so that Scott could continue to forge the signature of the deceased executor and divert money belonging to the estate.
In addition to the charges, the indictment contains a notice of forfeiture seeking $1.76 million.
Nino Tinari, Scott’s lawyer, said his client denies the charges as presented in the indictment. Scott is set to be arraigned Friday.
Insurance fraud committed by someone who should know better is one thing. But on top of that, this case features allegations of assault, foreign retaliatory detentions, computer hacking, extortion, spurned lovers, and revenge.
This former Biglaw partner left the practice complaining of back injuries that forever closed the door to the profession. In 2002, the carrier got a request to provide long-term disability benefits. But the carrier never really trusted the partner — because who really trusts lawyers — and conducted video surveillance and multiple independent medical examinations.
Late last week, a federal appeals court sided with the insurance company, agreeing that the partner was more than likely faking it and writing up the whole scandalous tale….
Terri Truitt was a partner at Mayer Brown in its Houston office, specializing in international oil and gas litigation. Correction, she was a partner at THE BIGLAW firm of Mayer Brown, because The New Republic informed us that Mayer Brown is the only Biglaw firm out there. They also made it pretty clear that being a partner there was a horrible experience (even if most of the perils described in the article happened years after Truitt left active practice).
Truitt suffered lower back and leg pain that eventually drove her to leave practice and seek benefits on the grounds that these injuries barred her from the regular practice of law. Having worked with exceptional attorneys with chronic back problems and even in wheelchairs, I’m incredulous. But Truitt suggested that her practice required intense physical effort.
For example, “lifting and handling boxes in excess of 25 pounds.” I have one word for you: associates.
In fairness to Truitt, she claimed her particular practice required long, international flights to far-flung locales like Sweden, Turkmenistan, and Pottsylvania. That could present a problem if you don’t get one of those Virgin Atlantic flights with the beds, I suppose.
But her carrier, Unum, never really believed her:
This continuing review also produced evidence inconsistent with Truitt’s disability. For example, surveillance videos showed Truitt walking, driving, and bending down, and lifting and carrying boxes, bags, coolers, pumpkins, and a dog. After conducting an Independent Medical Examination (“IME”), orthopedic surgeon Michael Graham found that “it is clear that [Truitt] has little or no physical impairment.”
Unum cut her off once, but relented after a brief clash of experts. Then the case got really crazy:
Around the same time that Truitt’s benefits were reinstated, a man identifying himself as Andrew Mark Thomas called Unum. Thomas said: that he had been in a personal relationship with Truitt for “a number of years”; that Truitt had him “locked up” and deported to the United Kingdom; that, as a result, he wanted “to see the b**** locked up”; and that he had photos, travel itineraries, and other documents that showed that Truitt was not totally disabled. Thomas sent Unum a follow-up email asking to be paid six times “the current monthly payments made to” Truitt in exchange for providing “complete evidence that [she] is obtaining monthly (disability) payments under false preten[s]es.” He warned: “This is a one[-]time offer, and no further thought will be given if you decide to decline.”
Extortion? Foreign detention? It’s not clear the extent of the “personal relationship” Thomas alleges, either. Thomas sounds totally crazy seriously aggrieved. Too bad Thomas let Unum know just how much he hated Truitt because Unum realized they didn’t need to buy the cow when they could get the milk for free:
Unum responded that it “does not pay for fraud[-]related information,” but that Thomas was “free to call” if he was willing “to provide this information without compensation.”
Thomas proceeded to provide, without compensation, some emails purportedly sent by Truitt. Unum asked Thomas if there were “any additional emails/information available which might shed additional light regarding this case?” Responding that “this is personal to me,” Thomas provided Unum with additional emails. In total, Thomas provided more than 600 pages of emails, spanning March 2005 to July 2007.
The emails — summarized over the course of multiple pages of the opinion — show that Truitt was an extensive world traveler, despite her stated inability to sit still on an international flight for hours. Her defense: vacation travel is way less demanding than work travel, which is true, but not likely to sway the carrier paying you upwards of $1 million in benefits because you claim to be “bed-ridden for upwards of 15 hours a day.” Worse still, the emails demonstrated that Truitt was actively practicing law on the side while telling Unum she could never practice again.
But even worse for Truitt, the emails matched up suspiciously with her correspondence with the carrier:
• Truitt contacted Unum on August 20, 2005 to say: that her condition had gotten worse; that her mother was taking care of her; that she would not be able to attend an FCE scheduled for September 2, 2005; and that she would not be available until September 24, 2005. Yet Truitt’s travel records showed that she was traveling in Europe between August 7, 2005 and September 22, 2005.
• Truitt told Unum in an April 24, 2006 letter that, since a March 1, 2006 FCE, she had “been confined to bed rest for approximately 15 hours per day.” Yet video surveillance on April 6, 2006 showed Truitt “driving for most of the day and removing several items from her vehicle.”
• Truitt told physician Levine during a June 9, 2006 IME that she had stayed in bed for 15 hours a day since the March 1, 2006 FCE. Yet “[d]uring this time period, some of the activities she was performing included international traveling, working, purchasing tickets to attend a Gala event, riding and keeping up two acres of property by herself.”
But Thomas wasn’t telling Unum everything:
Truitt sent Unum a three-page affidavit. Truitt recounted how she had been assaulted by Thomas. She then stated: that Thomas was “a computer and hacker expert”; that he “copied onto his laptop virtually all of the data from my personal computer”; and that his “laptop also has computer hacking programs and communications stating that Mr. Thomas was planning to ‘grass’ me up to UNUM and steal money from me.” Truitt characterized an email purportedly from Thomas—in which he threatened to tell Unum that he had “detailed knowledge & evidence of a long[-]term fraud being commi[t]ted by a[n] insured client of Unum”—as “threatening to send false information to UNUM.” She also asserted that “[n]one of the statements Mr. Thomas threatened to make to UNUM are true.”
Along with the affidavit, Truitt sent Unum documents confirming that Thomas pled guilty to assaulting Truitt by strangling her during a November 2007 camping trip. She also sent medical records, tax returns, and relevant case law.
So now Unum had some damning electronic evidence, but the source was allegedly a violent extortionist computer hacker.
Unum believed the emails and cut off Truitt’s benefits, prompting the former partner to file suit, alleging that Unum acted arbitrarily and capriciously in putting faith in anything Thomas sent them.
The Fifth Circuit disagreed with Truitt, finding that Unum’s faith in Thomas was merely part of an extensive investigation into the partner’s claimed disability.
And there you have it. If any of you other Mayer Brown partners were reading The New Republic and contemplating a severance package a la insurance fraud, you need to do a much better job committing to the role.
Want to read the entire sordid opinion, along with all the damaging email excerpts? It’s all on the next page…