Showing posts with label Courts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Courts. Show all posts

Friday, April 7, 2017

Judge reassigned after accused of wrongly locking up suspects for contempt

Judge reassigned after accused of wrongly locking up suspects for contempt
Cook County judge being reassigned over contempt of court issues
A Cook County judge has been removed from her post in criminal court following allegations that she wrongly ordered litigants locked up for contempt of court.
The Cook County Circuit Court's executive committee, a panel of supervising judges, took the rare action against Judge Gloria Chevere after preliminarily concluding that her rulings may have resulted in "possible threat of injury to the public and to the orderly administration of justice," according to a news release issued Wednesday by the office of Chief Judge Timothy Evans.
The news release was not specific about the rulings. However, an investigative report released about a week ago by Medill Watchdog and WGN-TV found that Chevere sent defendants to jail for contempt 30 times over the past four years.
Eight young men, according to the investigation, were sent to jail for wearing pants that sagged too low. During the same time frame, the report found, most Cook County judges hadn't sent anyone to jail for contempt.
The decision to reassign Chevere was announced after the court's 18-member executive committee met with her Monday to review allegations brought against her, according to the news release.
Chevere, who was elected in 2006, had been hearing Chicago misdemeanor and ordinance cases. She will be reassigned to hearing civil, nonjury or administrative matters, according to the release. The reassignment is pending "ultimate investigation and finding in the matter," according to the release, which also noted Chevere was assigned to the Illinois Supreme Court Peer Mentoring Program.
It was unclear when the committee would finalize its investigation into the allegations that Chevere failed to follow appropriate procedures prior to finding litigants in direct criminal contempt of court.
Chevere and Evans could not immediately be reached.
In 2012, the Judicial Performance Commission of Cook County, which evaluates judges with an eye toward improving their effectiveness, reported that she had trouble with "temperament and diligence" and made erratic rulings, which some attributed to her not being prepared.
Tribune reporter Cynthia Dizikes contributed.
mmrodriguez@tribpub.com
Copyright © 2017, Chicago Tribune

Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Forbidden: The Fool’s Challenge

Forbidden: The Fool’s Challenge

harrassmentAll you people claiming to advocate for the elderly and disabled, just who do you think you are to challenge judicial decisions, facilities, attorneys, conservators, guardians and fiduciaries?  They are, after all, proven, by their positions, to be above reproach.  How dare you challenge their intent, actions and/or character!
Judges, attorneys, CEO’s and others in charge have proven by the stations they have risen to, to be of perfection… the elite of the world… the all-knowing… and the all honest.  Never do they take advantage of their positions for personal financial gain nor to have a personal agenda in play.  Never do they do anything beneath their position.  To suggest otherwise is to be singled out to be disgraced and to possibly be labelled a threat or even mentally unbalanced.
I’m not sure what has happened to common sense and healthy thought process, but some kind of virus has been on the attack, it would seem.  Facts seem to be subjective or totally irrelevant.  It’s almost as though we are living in the “mad house” out here in the everyday world.  Too many things, arguments and decisions are outright crazy.
We have various Courts that worry about individuals taking advantage of the elderly or disabled, while signing off on outrageous fees for attorneys, appointed guardians and so forth.  What is the difference between the latter and the former?  Oh, is it because the latter is condoned by the courts and protected by some carelessly written law or skillful misinterpretation?  That somehow makes one right and the other wrong?
Worse than the money drain by the courts and appointed anointed-ones is the power to isolate the victims.  (Yes, victims.  What else would you call the people, who suddenly are imprisoned and forced to be and have done unto them what they would not, and do not, want done unto them and theirs?)
How can someone that robs another of companionship, enjoyment, freedom, money, property and simply an existence called living, be considered humane?  Animals are treated better than many of the elderly and disabled thrown into the system, because they could be thrown into the system — even if by a wrongful technicality in the law or by a court that is complicit due to bias or simply doesn’t look beyond the surface or listen to the bothersome advocates or nobodies that dare speak against the supposed “perfect” attorneys, professional guardians and such?  They never lie or steal or do unethical things, now do they?
In recent news, we have heard…
“WASHINGTON — Three central Ohio nursing homes were among 33 in 11 states cited for improper care and billing practices yesterday as part of a $38 million settlement among a major nursing-home company, the U.S. Department of Justice and the state of Ohio.
“The announcement in Washington and Columbus resolved an investigation by the federal government, Ohio and seven other states into charges that Extendicare of Canada provided services at those 33 homes that were “materially substandard” or “worthless” because the company did not provide care to residents that meets federal standards, according to the settlement agreement.”  (Federal investigation finds three local nursing homes lacking )
Now wait a minute.  I thought “all” facilities provided only the best of care and that complainers were just making things up or exaggerating.  They weren’t?
More recent news…
“The Ohio Supreme Court has suspended Akron attorney Rami M. Awadallah from practicing law after ruling that he fraudulently and deceptively represented several of his clients — including some in Lorain County — during court proceedings.”  (Ohio Supreme Court suspends area attorney)
What’s that?  An attorney “fraudulently and deceptively represented several of his clients”?  But… but… but… I thought that was impossible?  I thought “all” attorneys “always” spoke nothing but the truth and “always” acted in the best interest of the client or ward.  He didn’t?  What’s up with this?
More in the news…
“Paul S. Kormanik, a Columbus attorney considered up until two months ago to be legal guardian to more incompetent people than anyone else in the nation, was indicted today on theft charges by a Franklin County grand jury.
Prosecutor Ron O’Brien and Attorney General Mike DeWine will announce the charges this afternoon after the grand jury determined there was sufficient evidence that Kormanik stole about $41,000 from two of his wards.”  (Lawyer indicted for theft from those he was supposed to protect)
An attorney — a legal guardian — was indicted for what?  Stealing?  Stealing from people he was the guardian for?  Oh my!  Bubble buster!
While we are talking about a system lacking perfection and often tilted towards the powerful, though not necessarily the righteous or side with the cleanest of hands, let’s return, for a moment, to discussion involving isolation of the wards.  What judge or guardian or facility could possibly think isolation of a non-violent, non-contagious person is a good thing?
Decades ago, researchers found there is such a thing as “failure to thrive”.  It actually exists.  There is no question.   Why then, would anyone place another person in isolation and risk that person dying due to “failure to thrive”?  Why?  How can it be justified?  It can’t!  Therefore, I believe, anyone involved in isolating a non-violent, non-contagious person, should have to answer why they should not be charged with kidnapping and abuse or even murder, should the person die as a result.
I can think of numerous cases where people have been thrown into isolation and the ironies surrounding it all is out there in a suburb of the Twilight Zone.  Yes, so amazing is it all that I’m surprised a “duh” isn’t permanently imprinted upon both the perps and the out-of-touch — can’t get it — zombie followers that go around drooling false talking points, as though it is gospel, while alleging the truth-tellers are the liars.
 When a ward is put into isolation, who is the threat?  The one that ordered the isolation or the one challenging it?
When a petition is presented to starve & dehydrate a ward, who is the threat?  The person who did the petitioning or the one that fights for life, visitation, rehabilitation and stimulation?
The answers should be quite easy to figure out, but instead, it looks as though too much power and trust has been placed where not deserved.  It would seem, according to recent news, that we can’t always assume the courts and appointed anointed-ones are of perfection and holier than thou after all.  Maybe sometimes they are up to no good and their word isn’t worth what comes out of a donkey’s rump.  And, maybe sometimes people are wrong, but without any ill-intent.  Maybe they just lost sight and are blinded by self-preservation and inability to admit error.  But how do we know?  How do we know, if we don’t inquire and investigate behind the curtain, especially a curtain pulled tightly, as if to keep any from peeking in?
Advocates are necessary in a world that seems to have lost its way.  A world with too many who have come to believe good is evil and evil is good.  People that see the lie as truth and the truth as lie.  People who often admire the wrong-doer and find fault with the victim and the victim’s advocates.  People who aren’t even aware any longer that they might be wrong, because they are somehow “entitled”.  Aren’t they supposed to get more and be treated better than those they treat so poorly?
No?  Who says?  Who dares to challenge the new rule of they who control the lives and assets of vulnerable ones ordered to be incompetent, even though they — the vulnerable — might not be as incompetent or alone as decreed by a court?
Who dares to give challenge?
The advocates, whether they be professional advocates or family or friends or even concerned citizens made aware of someone’s plight — that’s who dares give challenge!
Yes, true advocates are necessary as long as the madness and wrongness reigns.  May the war be quickly won and the vulnerable-victims placed in the hands of those who dare to truly and unselfishly care!
It’s time to challenge!  It’s time to win!  It’s time to give lives back to those who have been violated by a system gone wrong!

Friday, April 4, 2014

Rogue alcoholic court reporter kept writing ‘I hate my job’

Rogue alcoholic court reporter kept writing ‘I hate my job’

An alcoholic Manhattan court stenographer went rogue, channeling his inner “Shining” during a high-profile criminal trial and repeatedly typing, “I hate my job, I hate my job” instead of the trial dialogue, sources told The Post.
The bizarre antics by Daniel Kochanski, who has since been fired, wreaked havoc on some 30 Manhattan court cases, sources said, and now officials are scrambling to repair the damage.
One high-level source said his “gibberish” typing may have jeopardized hard-won convictions by giving criminals the chance to claim crucial evidence is missing.
Kochanski’s botched transcripts include the 2010 mortgage-fraud trial of Aaron Hand, who was also convicted of trying to hire a hit man to take out a witness against him.
A source familiar with the case said Kochanski’s transcripts of that trial were a total mess.
“It should have been questions and answers — instead it was gibberish,” the source said.
And in a scene right out of 1980’s “The Shining,” where Jack Nicholson’s off-the-rails writer repeatedly types “All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy,” a source said of Kochanski: “He hit random keys or wrote, ‘I hate my job. I hate my job. I hate my job,’ over and over.”
Claudia Trupp, of the Center for Appellate Litigation, said her office was handling the appeals in Hand’s and nine other cases.
“I never had a situation where a single court reporter was responsible for so much damage,” she said.
Kochanski, 43, was fired in March 2012 for misconduct, said Office of Court Administration spokesman David Bookstaver.
Sources said the Manhattan DA’s Office arrested Kochanski and forced him to try to make sense of his shorthand typing.
But that effort apparently failed. Judges have been holding “reconstruction hearings” at which everyone involved in a case has to testify about what they remember.
“This situation is terrible for everybody,” Trupp said. “It’s very difficult to come up with a sufficient record based on everybody’s recollection years after the event.”
The troubled stenographer’s dad, Ed Kochanski, said his son “became an alcoholic” about five years ago, costing him his marriage and job.
He said his son was in rehab when they last spoke about three years ago.
Ex-wife Heather Kochanski said, “The pressure of that job pushed him over the edge, leading him to lose everything.”
By phone Wednesday, Kochanski denied screwing up his transcripts.
“I never typed gibberish. I always did my job 100 percent. I was let go because of substance abuse,” he said.
“I’m in recovery. July will be one year I’m clean,” he said.
Additional reporting by Steven Hirsch and Laurel Babcock

Sunday, December 22, 2013

New funds in ‘lost’ account of late heiress Huguette Clark

New funds in ‘lost’ account of late heiress Huguette Clark

More money is set to pour into the $300 million estate of the late copper heiress Huguette Clark after a bank reported an unclaimed checking account in her name.
More than two years after Clark died at the age of 104 in May 2011, JPMorgan Chase told the state Comptroller’s Office that it has been sitting on a pile of her cash.
Officials in the office refused to say how much money is involved.
But the estate’s attorney — who had been litigating the case since before Clark died and had never heard of that account — said Chase told him that it was “not an insignificant” amount.
The lawyer, John Morken, said that it was a total mystery why Chase waited until this year to report the unclaimed funds.
A spokeswoman for Chase told The Post that it was the estate’s job to contact the bank about the money.
She declined to comment on specifics of the Clark funds. But she said that the bank contacts its clients about such matters only after an account has been inactive for more than three years.
Clark was a frequent customer of the bank, writing checks to her nurse ranging from $20,000 to $500,000, and even overdrawing the account in staggering amounts — including by $49,000 in 2004.
A source told The Post that the heiress’ untouched account was at a local Chase branch.
The source said it was not uncommon for wealthy clients like Clark to work with both the private side of the bank — where she made larger transactions — and the retail side at her neighborhood Manhattan branch.
A court-appointed attorney is working with the bank to transfer the assets into Clark’s estate.
Whatever is in the dormant checking account will go to the Bellosguardo Foundation — an arts and cultural nonprofit at Clark’s $85 million Santa Barbara, Calif., mansion that also houses her $1.7 million doll collection, according to court documents.
Huguette was the eccentric, doll-obsessed daughter of railroad baron, copper king and US Sen. William Clark, whose fortune rivaled that of the Carnegies and Rockefellers.
Her estate reached a settlement over a disputed will with 19 of her distant relatives in September, but its executors are still embroiled in a $105 million lawsuit with Beth Israel Hospital, where the heiress lived for the last 20 years of her life.
The executors charge the hospital and one of its doctors with keeping the heiress “sequestered from the world” so they could siphon millions of dollars in rent and gifts from her.
Beth Israel “officials deliberately kept Huguette’s status as a patient secret from the hospital’s legal department and state regulators in order to keep here there and access her money,” court papers say.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Perelman scion grilled over greed in inheritance battle

Perelman scion grilled over greed in inheritance battle

Revlon billionaire Ron Perelman’s daughter, Samantha, was set to inherit at least $20 million from her mother’s family — including a 30.5-carat ring, Manhattan co-op and New Jersey manse.
She’s also in line to net a fortune from late mom Claudia ­Cohen’s $78 million estate — not to mention her father’s multibillion-dollar empire.
But even that’s not good enough to satisfy the 23-year-old, her uncle’s lawyer charged in a Hackensack, NJ, court Tuesday.
“You didn’t say ‘I want to inherit $100 million to $50 million’?” demanded lawyer Benjamin Clarke, who is defending James Cohen against Samantha Perelman’s claim that he coerced his ailing dad into cutting her out of his $600 million Hudson News fortune.
He was referring to a 2007 meeting between Perelman and her grandfather Robert Cohen, James and Claudia’s dad.
“I wouldn’t characterize it as such,’’ Samantha replied to the cross-examination on her second day of testimony.
“You didn’t say ‘[I] want a half or a third of your business’ to your grandfather?’’ Clarke asked.
Perelman denied it again.
Painting Perelman as a greedy, ungrateful rich kid, Clarke said Samantha coldly filed suit against her uncle 15 days after his dad, Robert Cohen, died at age 86.
Samantha tried to get her grandfather declared legally ­incompetent after he changed his will, but her bid failed.
At one point, Clarke suggested that the Ivy League grad student was pushing for something that wasn’t hers — and that she hardly needed any more money, anyway.
“You realize that your grandfather had the right to treat you as an individual, not as a replacement for your mother?’’ he said.
“He had consistently treated me and my mother the same,” Perelman answered.
“On the subject of your grandfather’s intentions towards you, do you contend that your grandfather did not know that you are the daughter of one of the wealthiest men in the world?’’ Clarke asked.
She replied, “I don’t know how that has anything to do with it.”
The defense also tried to hammer home the notion that Ron Perelman was pulling all the strings in the lawsuit.
Clarke noted that Claudia ­Cohen’s 2004 will would have given her daughter $5 million at age 25 and then half of her remaining $73 million fortune at age 40.
But in 2007, as she lay dying of cancer at Sloan-Kettering, Cohen changed her will to make her ex, Ron, executor with sole control over the purse strings.
Clarke hinted that Samantha would do his bidding as long as he controlled the money.
Samantha grew testy, saying her dad “was [her mom’s] best friend.”
“You can’t use Ronald Perelman as a pawn,’’ she seethed. “It was for Claudia Cohen. He was working as an executor [when her will was changed in 2007]. He’s not this bad guy that we’re all trying to beat up.’’

Friday, November 8, 2013

Judge facing discipline refused to take deposition oath

ILNews

Judge facing discipline refused to take deposition oath

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrint AddThis
Marion Superior Judge Kimberly Brown refused to be sworn during a deposition before the Judicial Qualifications Commission – a videotaped moment of defiance used against her Monday at the outset of her weeklong disciplinary case.

Over the objection of Brown’s attorneys, the three-judge panel of special masters allowed into evidence the judge’s videotaped refusal to swear to tell the truth during an Aug. 1 deposition in the case that now includes 47 counts of judicial misconduct.

“I am always an officer of the court,” Brown says in refusing to take the oath. “I am a judge.”

Meanwhile, Brown’s attorneys said the case against her is a result of problems with her court staff and that she’s being singled out for delayed releases of criminal defendants that have happened with other Marion Superior judges.

Brown was the first witness called in a hearing expected to last at least through the end of this week and possibly into next week. Brown wiped away tears as she attempted to explain why she refused to be sworn in the deposition. “I believe I’m always an officer of the court and therefore always bound to the truth,” she said.

“But you decided to do something different today,” JQC attorney Adrienne Meiring said after Brown took an oath before the masters. Retired Monroe Circuit Judge Viola Taliaferro is presiding over the panel that includes Boone Superior Judge Rebecca S. McClure and Lake Superior Judge Sheila M. Moss.

Meiring pointed Brown to rules of evidence requiring witnesses be sworn and admitted into evidence the statutes governing oaths that judges and other public officials such as police officers must take. Taliaferro asked Brown multiple times to explain why she believed she wasn’t required to swear an oath at the deposition.

“I wasn’t basing it on anything other than I’m always an officer of the court,” Brown said.

Meiring argued that Brown’s refusal to be sworn at the deposition illustrated the nature of many of the complaints against her. The charges against Brown include allegations that she delayed release of at least nine defendants – in one case for 22 days – failed to properly oversee her court, was hostile toward parties who came before and retaliated against court staff who complained, among other things.

Meiring opened by using Brown’s alleged words against her – “This isn’t McDonald’s … It’ll get ruled on when it gets ruled on,” Meiring said. “This is not simply a situation of a bad day.

“This is systemic neglect and failing to do her judicial duty,” she said, calling Brown’s demeanor “rampant disrespect and abuse of various court officials and actors who came before her.”

Brown’s attorney Aaron Haith sought to shift blame from the judge to a “sour staff” that he said she inherited when she moved between criminal court divisions at the City-County Building. Brown hears a docket of mainly domestic misdemeanor and Class D felony cases.

“It is a high-stress position for a judge,” Haith said. He said Brown also tried to change the court staff but was unable to do so. He told the judges that the evidence presented to them this week will show questions of staff integrity, staff knowledge and staff training.

The quality of staff performance, Haith said, “can be a help or a hindrance to the court.”

Haith also argued that Brown was being singled out for oversights that she has in common with other judges on the Marion Superior bench. “They all had problems … with delayed releases” of people wrongly held at the Marion County Jail, he said.

“They’re not judged,” Haith said. “Judge Brown is.”

Haith said the Marion Superior Executive Committee has instituted training for judges because of problems of delayed releases for which Brown is being disciplined, and he cited a lack of communications between the courts and the jail for the problem of defendants being held longer than a judge has ordered. “You will find all the judges are suffering or worried” about the problems, Haith told the panel.

Meiring later pressed Brown on her initial responses to the JQC’s charges against her in which she accepted responsibility in some cases and later denied responsibility in an amended response.

“I’m denying that I violated the Code of Judicial Conduct,” Brown said in response to questions about the underlying facts of a case in which a defendant was wrongly jailed.

Meiring argued that Brown had shown a lack of cooperation with the commission, an assertion to which Haith objected. Meiring noted that in depositions, Brown had responded to yes-or-no questions by saying “the record speaks for itself” 106 times.

Brown’s hearing is open to the public and will continue this week in the Indiana Supreme Court courtroom or conference room at the Statehouse.