Showing posts with label Paul S. Kormanik. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paul S. Kormanik. Show all posts

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Lawyer booked on charges he stole from guardianship clients

Lawyer booked on charges he stole from guardianship clients

By  The Columbus Dispatch  •  
REQUEST TO BUY THIS PHOTO
BROOKE LAVALLEY | DISPATCH FILE PHOTO
Lawyer Paul Kormanik

A Columbus attorney charged with stealing from two people he was supposed to be caring for turned himself in to authorities this morning and was booked into the Franklin County Jail. 

Paul S. Kormanik surrendered at 10:22 this morning and was later released on $100,000 bond. He was ordered to surrender his passport. 

He was ordered to have no contact with family members or friends of the two wards from whom he is accused of stealing about $41,000 in 2012 and earlier this year. 

Kormanik was appointed by the Franklin County Probate Court to be their guardian. 

Kormanik has not returned calls or emails seeking comment. His attorney, Richard Cline, said state law does not allow him to make any comments about the case, though he did not cite the law that outlines such a gag order. Still he said that Kormanik "has faith in the legal system he served for three decades." 

Kormanik is expected to appear in court in the next several weeks to enter his plea on third- and fourth-degree felony theft charges before a trial date can be set. 

He faces up to 4 1/2 years in prison if convicted. 

In 2012, after Robert Hart died, Kormanik made withdrawals from Hart’s bank account totaling about $34,000, according to the grand jury indictment. 

Kormanik deposited the money into his personal checking account and used the funds “to benefit himself,” according to the indictment. 

In another case, the indictment accuses Kormanik of transferring the remaining $7,200 that Edith Linnabary had left from a pension into his personal account two years after she died. 

Kormanik is then accused of giving $7,000 of that money to his wife.

WEEKLY ADS


Wednesday, August 6, 2014

Court: Guardian can’t take new cases

Court: Guardian can’t take new cases


Franklin County Probate Court has barred a lawyer who is under criminal investigation from obtaining any new guardianship cases. ’
The court has held hearings the past two months asking the lawyer, Paul S. Kormanik, to explain his billing practices. They were among the potential abuses exposed in a series of stories in The Dispatch that detailed a broken system for caring for people the court has deemed incompetent to care for themselves.
The court has found in several cases that Kormanik misused a taxpayer-supported fund that pays attorney guardians up to $420 annually to handle legal matters for indigent people.
“Of the 17 cases thus far reviewed, the court found cause for concern in 16 cases,” Judge Robert G. Montgomery wrote in a court order. “Based upon the large percentage of cases with irregularities causing concern ... the court will impose a moratorium on appointing attorney Kormanik as guardian on any further cases.”
Court officials also said they are investigating several other guardians, some of them also lawyers, but declined to name specific cases.
Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine’s office and Franklin County Prosecutor Ron O’Brien are also investigating Kormanik’s billing practices and his use of Medicaid funds. That investigation is expected to take several months.
Kormanik did not respond to questions about the criminal investigation. As for the court hearings, he said the court is trying to enforce rules that it previously had not explained to him.
“I have not received a copy of the rules and understand that the rules are not written,” he said.
Montgomery’s decision also comes as the Ohio Supreme Court and state legislators are discussing new uniform standards to better protect the more than 65,000 Ohioans who are in guardianships. Three Ohio Republicans — state Sen. Shannon Jones of Springboro, state Rep. Dorothy Pelanda of Marysville and House Speaker William G. Batchelder of Medina — have called for hearings to spur changes.
A probate judge or magistrate has the authority to order the establishment of a guardianship. A guardian appointed by the court then takes control of decision-making for the person declared incompetent, also known as a ward. A guardian can request the relationship without ever meeting the ward or speaking with family members.
The Dispatch investigation “Unguarded,” online at Dispatch.com/unguarded, found that unscrupulous lawyers were billing legal fees for non-legal work. One, for example, billed a ward’s estate more than $1,000 to talk to her family by phone about planning her funeral.
That lawyer, Kevin A. Craine, also is under investigation by the Ohio Supreme Court’s disciplinary counsel, state and local authorities involved in Kormanik’s investigation told The Dispatch. The counsel is looking at possible ethics violations.
Audrey E. Varwig, an assistant disciplinary counsel, said she cannot comment on any reviews or confirm whether there is an investigation. Craine did not return calls seeking comment.
The probate court is not reviewing Craine’s cases.
The Dispatch also uncovered wrongdoing by family members who neglected loved ones and abused them. Much of the abuse was allowed to take place because neither guardians nor the probate court checked on the wards, in some cases for years.
A handful of lawyers are responsible for more than 1,000 of the county’s 4,000 adult wards. Kormanik has nearly 400 wards and remains in control of most of them.
Court officials said they will hold more hearings about his cases.
The court is reviewing how Kormanik is able to submit to the court thousands of dollars in legal fees for wards who are labeled indigent because they have less than $1,500 in assets, yet also pay himself from money belonging to his wards.
In many cases, Kormanik is guardian of the person only, meaning he can make medical and living decisions for a ward but has no control over finances.
The court has asked him in several instances to explain where he got the money and why he opened up bank accounts on behalf of a ward but never reported those accounts to the court.
Mike Shively’s uncle is in a guardianship under Kormanik. He is one of the 17 wards whose cases the court reviewed.
“My uncle has not been served adequately at all by Kormanik, and we’ve tried and tried to get explanations from him about my uncle’s finances,” Shively said. “We are trying to get Kormanik removed as guardian.”
Last week, the court rejected about 150 legal bills that Kormanik had submitted. He filed the bills in the event that an indigent ward comes into money and is able to pay.
Many of those bills charged questionable “legal fees” for such things as cleaning out a ward’s house, talking to a family member about the ward’s care or talking to the ward directly. The court had previously approved nearly all such bills without holding a hearing.
Montgomery told The Dispatch in April that the hearings are routinely waived because they would bog down the court.
lsullivan@dispatch.com
@DispatchSully